I have just seen Eagle Eye, a high-octane flick about a malfunctioning super-snooper computer that orchestrates a series of unfortunate incidents leading to the murder of innocent people.
The stuff of pure fantasy, I assumed, until I read last week’s government leak to the Sunday Times. Apparently we will soon be required to hand in a passport before we buy a mobile phone
Officially we are now all terrorists.
The Communications Data Bill proposes all kind s of electronic surveillance covering emails, web browsing and mobile phones to make sure we are all behaving as model citizens. The big gap in the spooks’ plan is that more than half the 72 million mobile phones in Britain are pay-as-you-go. Many of these are unregistered and untraceable back to the owner.
The idea is that if Osama bin Laden buys a Virgin SIM card from the Phones 4 U for a tenner, no one can trace the call if he orders the next terrorist strike. So the whole population should be treated a nation of terrorists, just in case.
Those who don’t have a passport – and there are millions of them – can’t have a phone. Those who don’t have a driving licence – generally the under 18s – can’t have a phone.
The solution… they can all buy a biometric ID card for £300. ID cards installed; government in charge of sensitive personal data; Americans happy. Job done.
The phone companies will be livid. No surprise phones for Christmas for the children next year, unless Mum carts them off to the shops with a passport and a fingerprint pad.
What utterly insulting garbage. Perhaps some grunt in the Home Office leaked the story in a misguided attempt to “canvass public opinion” on this stupid idea, presumably to impress the Americans that we have done our homework on the latest plan for mass surveillance.
A short lesson in commerce and common sense may help these Whitehall buffoons learn something about the real world.
The first point is that a large number of pay-as-you-go phones are already traceable because most people are happy to top up their phone credits at cashpoint machines. The banks already hold their personal data which can be linked immediately to the phone number typed in.
I dare say a few criminals would top up their phones with cash at newsagents to avoid tracing, but more likely the phone will have been stolen, and some hapless stockbroker could find his phone unknowingly used in a crime.
And how would the spooks handle the data? Leave it on a train perhaps, for someone else to make sense of. There is no way the creaking state IT systems could process the information.
To illustrate the point, all cars in the UK must by law be registered with the DVLC, and quite rightly there are stiff penalties for those who don’t. That doesn’t alter the fact that hundreds of thousands of older cars are unregistered because people sell them and don’t bother to forward the new owners’ details.
Car theft is big business, and a simple switch to false number plates renders the DVLC computer powerless to track them.
The same would happen with mobile phones. There would be a mass trade in mobile phones with SIM cards installed via Ebay, at car boot sales and in street markets.
The phone companies could threaten to switch off all unregistered SIM Cards, but the phone shops could never cope with reregistering 30 million phones free of charge, and I don’t imagine many people would be prepared to pay.
You only need to look at the brisk trade in mobile phones on Ebay to see what would happen if this crackpot scheme was forced in. It would guarantee a big business in SIM cards being sold offshore, much like CDs and DVDs are sold today, far away from the prying eyes of Britain’s Big Brother – or even the Eagle Eye – state.